Paoli Homes for Sale

Paoli Homes for Sale

Welcome to Paoli, Indiana – a charming township nestled in the heart of Orange County, where small-town charm meets modern convenience. Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Paoli offers a delightful blend of rural tranquility and vibrant local culture. With its rich history and a welcoming atmosphere, this quaint town is perfect for families, retirees, and anyone looking to embrace a relaxed lifestyle.

As you explore the homes for sale in Paoli, you’ll discover a variety of options tailored to fit your needs. From cozy single-family homes with lush gardens to spacious properties with breathtaking views, there’s something for everyone. The real estate market here boasts affordability without sacrificing quality, making it an ideal choice for first-time buyers and seasoned homeowners alike.

Paoli is not just about beautiful homes; it’s also about community. Residents enjoy access to local parks, recreational activities, and charming shops that line the streets of the downtown area. The annual Paoli Festival and other community events foster a sense of belonging and provide opportunities to connect with neighbors.

For those who appreciate nature, the nearby Hoosier National Forest offers endless opportunities for hiking, camping, and exploring the great outdoors. With its excellent schools and safe neighborhoods, Paoli is a place where families can thrive.

If you’re looking for a home that combines comfort, community, and natural beauty, Paoli, Indiana, might just be your perfect match. Start your journey today and discover the enchanting properties waiting for you in this delightful township!

Newest Paoli Homes for Sale

109 S Triangle Rd, Paoli
$155,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202646965 MLS ⋅ 1,728 SqFt. ⋅ Natasha Johns
SCENIC. SPACIOUS. PRIVATE. Discover the charm of this beautiful FOUR bedroom, TWO bathroom stone home situated on 2.18 acres, offering peaceful surroundings and spectacular countryside views. As you arrive via the circular driveway, you'll appreciate the convenience of two separate attached one-car garages, providing additional parking and functionality. Take a moment to relax on the front porch and enjoy the breathtaking scenery. Step inside to a spacious living area featuring a cozy wood-burning fireplace, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Straight ahead, you'll find the kitchen, with the dining area conveniently located to the left, offering a comfortable layout for everyday living and entertaining. To the right of the living room are two bedrooms and a full guest bathroom. Continue through the kitchen to find the laundry area, two additional bedrooms, and a second full bathroom. Just off the kitchen, you'll also find access to the walkout basement, which conveniently leads into one of the attached garages. The property is currently served by well water, with public water available at the street. Electric and gas utilities are provided by the Town of Paoli. With its beautiful stone exterior, scenic acreage, functional layout, and stunning country views, this property offers a wonderful opportunity to enjoy the comfort and charm of peaceful country living.

109 S Triangle Rd, Paoli

Listing courtesy of Natasha Johns from Williams Carpenter Realtors.

729 E Water St, Paoli
$274,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202645736 MLS ⋅ 1,502 SqFt. ⋅ Arla Jean Frazier
729 E WATER STREET IS UNIQUELY NESTLED ON A ELEVATED DBL LOT (0.92 AC) OVERLOOKING THE HISTORIC PAOLI TOWN SQUARE WHERE COURTHOUSE BELLS CHIME IN THE DISTANCE TRANSPORTING YOU BACK TO AN ERA WHEN LIFE MOVED AT A MORE DELIBERATE PACE * PRIDE OF OWNERSHIP ABOUNDS IN THIS BEAUTIFUL 4 YR YOUNG MODERN BUNGALOW * CUSTOM BUILT WITH PASSIVE CONSTRUCTION PRINCIPLES TO MAXIMIZE WINTER SUN (WARMING) AND SUMMER SHADY BREEZE (COOLING) FOR YEAR ROUND ENERGY EFFICIENCY * EXCEPTIONAL CONSTRUCTION DETAILS INCLUDE LP SMART BOARD & BATTEN SIDING W/FACTORY BAKED 35/YR PAINT WARRANTY * ICF FOUNDATION BLOCKS OFFER DOUBLE-INSULATED REINFORCED CONCRETE * OVERSIZED QUAKER CASEMENT WINDOWS & SKYLIGHTS ALLOW FOR ABUNDANT NATURAL LIGHT * ENERGY EFFICIENT HVAC & NEW SOLAR PANELS PROJECTED TO "ZERO" OUT ELECTRIC COSTS * INTERIOR CASCADING CATHEDRAL CEILING ELEVATES YOUR LIVING SPACE * GLEAMING WOOD FLOORS ADD WARMTH THROUGHOUT * FLEXIBLE LIVING ROOM + DEN/LIBRARY AREA * WHITE & BRIGHT CUSTOM DREAM KITCHEN FEATURES CENTER ISLAND BREAKFAST BAR, SOLID SURFACE COUNTERS & S/S APPLIANCES * SEPARATE DINING ROOM * 2-BED ON MAIN LEVEL SHARE J&J FULL BATH WITH SLATE TILE FLOOR & TUB/SHOWER * OFFSET FRONT STAIRCASE LEADS TO COZY UPPER LEVEL LOFT AREA (PLUMBED FOR WET BAR) & BEDROOM 3 ENSUITE W/SEPARATE MINI-SPLIT HEAT/COOL SYSTEM & FULL BATH W/SLATE TILE FLOOR & CUSTOM TILED W/I SHOWER * UNLIMITED POSSIBILITIES EXIST IN THE FULL UNFINISHED W/O BASEMENT WITH 9.5’ CEILINGS, LAUNDRY & MECHANICAL ROOMS * STORAGE GALORE * NEWLY STAINED FRONT PORCH & BACK DECK OVERLOOK THE GENTLY ROLLING DOUBLE LOT W/MATURE TREES * NEW GRAVEL DRIVEWAY * WALKING DISTANCE TO TOWN SQUARE AND GREEN ACRES GOLF COURSE * ONE LOOK AND YOU WILL WANT TO CALL THIS HOME!

729 E Water St, Paoli

Listing courtesy of Arla Jean Frazier from Ever Real Estate, LLC.

925 W Oakwood Ln, Paoli
$445,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202644505 MLS ⋅ 4,496 SqFt. ⋅ Elmer Lambright
CUSTOM 4,500+/- SQ. FT. HOME ON 5 PRIVATE ACRES – PAOLI, INDIANA. A rare opportunity to own a distinctive custom-built home on 5 private acres, entirely within the town of Paoli. Enjoy the combination of in-town convenience, wooded privacy, wildlife, and an established homestead. This single-owner home offers 5–6 bedrooms, and 3.5 bathrooms. Features include a large stone fireplace, wood stove, screened porch, three-car garage, and a walk-out basement apartment providing flexible living arrangements or potential for multigenerational use or passive income. A large flex room with a sink offers further possibilities. The property includes solar panels, an attached root cellar/storm shelter, a large partially enclosed shed, additional outbuildings, and fiber-optic internet. The shared well has served the property and two neighboring households reliably for 36 years. Outdoor amenities include an established, seven-foot-fenced garden, irrigated blueberry cages, wooded trails, and abundant wildlife. The additional outbuildings accommodate gardening, storage, dogs, and chickens. Enjoy the privacy and versatility of an established homestead with room for gardening, recreation, and a variety of interests, all within town. *This is a part of a larger parcel which is being split. The parcel number reflects all parcels, and the taxes do as well*

925 W Oakwood Ln, Paoli

Listing courtesy of Elmer Lambright from eXp Realty, LLC. Cell: 812-653-4121

717 N Marshall Rd, Paoli
$550,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202644349 MLS ⋅ 4,816 SqFt. ⋅ Natasha Johns
GRAND. SECLUDED. EXCEPTIONAL. Discover this remarkable SIX bedroom, FOUR bathroom, one-owner home nestled on six scenic acres, offering an extraordinary blend of space, privacy, and amenities for everyday living and entertaining. As you travel down the circular driveway, you'll be welcomed by timeless curb appeal and beautifully designed outdoor spaces that invite you to relax and enjoy the surroundings. Step through the front porch into a spacious foyer that sets the tone for the home's elegant yet comfortable interior. To the left, the main-level primary suite provides convenience and privacy, while the formal dining room sits to the right, ready to host memorable gatherings. Straight ahead, the eat-in kitchen features abundant natural light, picturesque country views, and a cozy fireplace. Just beyond, a charming sitting room opens to a spacious enclosed back porch, creating another inviting space for quiet mornings or entertaining. The sitting area also connects to a large living room and a beautiful sunroom, bringing together indoor comfort and the beauty of the outdoors. Upstairs, a second primary suite offers its own fireplace and walk-in closet, along with four additional bedrooms and a guest bathroom. The finished basement expands the living space even further with a recreation room, library, generous storage areas, and convenient access from both the home and garage. The outdoor amenities make this property truly special. Enjoy an in-ground Grecian-style pool with a water slide and electric cover, plus a pool house cabana featuring a kitchen, half bath, bar, and sitting room. Additional recreational features include a concrete basketball court, a wooden playground with a watchtower lookout, and a charming original 150-year-old log cabin with a front porch. The cabin includes one bedroom and offers a unique space for guests, hobbies, or a private getaway. A stunning solarium provides a wonderful retreat for plant lovers, while the orchard of cherry, pear, and persimmon trees, along with a blackberry patch, adds to the property's appeal. An attached garage provides everyday convenience. Recent improvements include a complete renovation of the main floor, encompassing the living area, kitchen, sitting room, sun porch, breakfast room, primary bedroom, and bathroom. Additional updates include all-new windows and doors, double etched-glass front doors, new kitchen appliances, and a new washer and dryer. The home also features three gas fireplaces w

717 N Marshall Rd, Paoli

Listing courtesy of Natasha Johns from Williams Carpenter Realtors.

895 W Oakwood Ln, Paoli
$359,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202643841 MLS ⋅ 2,527 SqFt. ⋅ Arla Jean Frazier
DREAMING OF A PRIVATE RETREAT AT THE END OF YOUR DAY? 895 W OAKWOOD IS A PRIVATE LANE NESTLED IN THE WOODED HILLS OVERLOOKING HISTORIC PAOLI * BEAUTIFUL 3-BED, 2.5 BA CEDAR SIDED COTTAGE CUSTOM BUILT WITH PASSIVE CONSTRUCTION PRINCIPLES FOR YEAR ROUND ENERGY EFFICIENCY * PERFECTLY ORIENTED ON THE 2.08 AC LOT TO MAXIMIZE WINTER SUN (WARMING) AND SUMMER SHADY BREEZE (COOLING) * EXCEPTIONAL QUALITY CONSTRUCTION DETAILS INCLUDE PELLA WINDOWS/DOORS, 3-YO GEOTHERMAL HVAC, 1.5 YO METAL ROOF, FULL HOUSE CENTRAL VACUUM SYSTEM * THE LOVELY COTTAGE INTERIOR WELCOMES YOU LIKE A WARM HUG * MAIN LEVEL FLOWS FROM ENTRY TO LIVING ROOM W/BRICK WALL HEARTH, CAST IRON WOOD BURNING STOVE W/HEATILATOR, GLEAMING OAK HARDWOOD FLOORS CRAFTED FROM TIMBER HARVESTED FROM THE LAND, CUSTOM QUILTED BLINDS * BRIGHT & WHITE CHEF'S DREAM KITCHEN, BREAKFAST BAR, S/S APPLIANCES & WALK-IN PANTRY * SEPARATE DINING AREA * EXPANSIVE WINDOWS ALLOW FOR ABUANDANT NATURAL LIGHT & BREATH TAKING VIEWS NO MATTER THE SEASON * WOOD OFFSET SWEETHEART SPLIT STAIRCASE LEADS YOU UPSTAIRS * OWNER'S BEDROOM HAS WALK-OUT BALCONY FOR STAR GAZING * 2ND BEDROOM FEATURES SINK/VANITY * JACK-N-JILL BATH HAS BEEN BEAUTIFULLY UPDATED WITH CUSTOM TILED W/I SHOWER & DOUBLE VANITY * COZY UPPER LEVEL LOFT IS IDEAL FOR HOME-OFFICE/DEN (HIDDEN LAUNDRY SHOOT) * SWEETHEART STAIRCASE LEADS YOU TO A FULL PARTIALLY FINISHED W/O BASEMENT * 3RD BEDROOM HAS BRICK HEARTH FOR FUTURE WOOD STOVE & FULL BATH IDEAL FOR GUESTS OR MULTI-GENERATIONAL LIVING * 1/2 UNFINISHED AREA FEATURES LAUNDRY (GRAY WATER SEPARATED) MECHANICAL ROOM AND STORAGE ROOM * 1 CAR ATTACHED GARAGE * MULTI LEVEL-DECKS * OUTBUILDING WITH COVERED PATIO & LEAN-TO * CIRCULAR DRIVEWAY * CASCADING TREES AND STARS INCLUDED * ONE LOOK AND YOU WILL WANT TO CALL THIS HOME!

895 W Oakwood Ln, Paoli

Listing courtesy of Arla Jean Frazier from Ever Real Estate, LLC.

123 Nw 1st St, Paoli
$180,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202642054 MLS ⋅ 1,476 SqFt. ⋅ Natasha Johns
HISTORIC. CHARMING. INVITING. This THREE bedroom, ONE bathroom home sits on a 0.15-acre corner lot and offers beautiful historic details, natural woodwork, and a functional layout. Additional features include a 1-car attached garage, carport, and full walkout unfinished basement. Step onto the covered front porch and enter into the spacious living room, featuring a gas log fireplace and beautiful natural woodwork. Historic details throughout the home add warmth and character that are truly hard to replicate. From the living room, you'll find the formal dining room, which flows into the country kitchen. The kitchen also provides convenient access to the attached garage. Just off the kitchen is one bedroom, while two additional bedrooms and the full bathroom are located just off the dining room area. Main-level laundry adds everyday convenience. The full walkout unfinished basement provides plenty of additional storage space and potential for future use. Outside, the corner lot offers a welcoming setting with the covered front porch, carport, and convenient garage access. Some of the most recent updates include sewer pipes from house to town hook up in 2022 and wired security system in 2020. Utilities are provided by Town of Paoli, Orange Co REMC, and Indiana Natural Gas. Home comes complete with kitchen appliances and has the possibility of qualifying for 100% USDA financing. With its historic character, beautiful natural woodwork, functional floor plan, and convenient features, this charming home offers a wonderful opportunity to enjoy a piece of timeless character while making it your own.

123 Nw 1st St, Paoli

Listing courtesy of Natasha Johns from Williams Carpenter Realtors.

Start Your Search

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal noncommercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed by MLS GRID, and that the use of the MLS GRID Data may be subject to an end user license agreement prescribed by IRMLS as amended from time to time.


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!