Benton Homes for Sale

Welcome to Benton, Indiana – a hidden gem that beautifully combines small-town charm with modern conveniences. Nestled in the heart of the Hoosier State, Benton is a welcoming township that offers a peaceful lifestyle surrounded by picturesque landscapes and friendly neighbors. This idyllic community is perfect for those seeking a serene environment while still enjoying easy access to nearby urban amenities.

Benton is known for its rich agricultural heritage, offering residents a taste of rural living with the benefits of a close-knit community. The township is dotted with lovely parks, scenic walking trails, and family-friendly recreational areas, making it an ideal place for outdoor enthusiasts and families alike. With a strong sense of community spirit, Benton hosts various local events and festivals throughout the year, ensuring that there’s always something fun to participate in.

For those looking to call Benton home, you’re in luck! The real estate market here features a diverse range of homes for sale, catering to various budgets and preferences. From charming single-family homes with spacious yards to cozy cottages perfect for first-time buyers, Benton offers something for everyone. With competitive pricing and a variety of styles, you can find the perfect property to create lasting memories.

Whether you’re a young family, a retiree, or a professional seeking a peaceful retreat, Benton, Indiana, is the perfect place to put down roots. Explore the available homes for sale and discover the warmth and charm that this delightful township has to offer!

Newest Benton Homes for Sale

$349,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202640007 MLS ⋅ 2,302 SqFt. ⋅ Nicolas Wyse

Beautifully remodeled 3 Bed, 2 Full Bathroom home with a private backyard oasis in Fairfield schools. Enjoy all of the updates that await you, plus the Master Suite with a split floorplan and main level laundry. Finished family room in basement allows for room to spread out - but the home also has significant amount of storage, or space for future livable square footage.

216 Cindy Ct, Millersburg

Listing courtesy of Nicolas Wyse from RE/MAX Results. Office: 574-533-9581

$850,000

4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 202639544 MLS ⋅ 3,560 SqFt. ⋅ Kristi Gibbs

Conveniently located near Lake Lemon and Unionville Elementary, with downtown Bloomington and charming Nashville less than 20 minutes away, this home offers a beautifully modern interior and exceptional outdoor living spaces. The home's large wraparound porch welcomes you inside where you'll find a spacious living room with vaulted ceilings, a wood-burning fireplace with a mantel crafted from B & L Railroad timber and ties, and reclaimed timber beams. The custom Amish kitchen offers stainless appliances, including an induction cooktop and warming drawer, a large island, quartz and butcher block countertops, and stylish cabinetry. A generous laundry and mudroom adds convenient storage options. The main-level primary suite boasts a gorgeous bath with twin sink vanity, tiled shower and a large closet. Two large bedrooms, a full bath, and a versatile loft space complete the upper level. The finished walkout basement adds even more living and sleeping space, with an additional bedroom, a full bath, and a rec room perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Just off the garage, an impressive studio addition offers its own living room, chef's kitchen, full bath, and walk-in pantry. This flexible area is ideal for guests, a home office, or extra living space. The property's character continues outdoors, where a firepit, hiking trails, and a fenced raised-bed garden, all surrounded by the privacy and beauty of 15 acres, await. An attached 2-car garage, 40' x 30' detached garage with hydraulic lift, and a shed make storing equipment or recreational vehicles a breeze and offer ideal workshop and hobby spaces. This special property offers privacy, character, and craftsmanship in a beautiful Monroe County location.

9111 E State Road 45, Unionville

Listing courtesy of Kristi Gibbs from Century 21 Scheetz - Bloomington.

$630,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202639361 MLS ⋅ 3,790 SqFt. ⋅ Scott Newland

This 5-bedroom, 3.5 bath all-brick home can be your own private, wooded retreat with over 4,000 sq ft and on 6+ acres in Bent Pine Estates. And yet, you'll still be just 10 minutes to the mall and 12 minutes to IU campus. The main level includes 3 bedrooms, living room, eat-in kitchen plus a formal dining room. Additionally, there is a screened-in porch, a 4-car garage/workshop and a large deck overlooking the pool. On the lower level are two more bedrooms, another full bathroom, family room, kitchenette, huge storage room and an extra room used as a workout room but could be a media room, office, playroom, storm shelter or more. The home features 2 fireplaces--one on each level--a covered in-gound pool and deck, and it backs up to conservation land.

6308 N Bent Pine Dr, Bloomington

Listing courtesy of Scott Newland from Brawley Real Estate. Office: 844-254-7368

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202639030 MLS ⋅ 1,604 SqFt. ⋅ Jesse Riegsecker

AUCTION!! This property to sell at auction on 10-17 at 12 noon. This 10+ acre property is to be offered in 2 parcels with Parcel 1 being offered with 3 acres, the 3 bed 1 bath home, a large barn with multiple lean-to and smaller outbuildings. Parcel 2 is being offered with 7+ acres which is currently productive farmland. This parcel also has a small orchard at the rear of the property. Auction open houses to be held on September 26th & October 3 & 10th from 10-12. If you are looking to be in the Syracuse area or in Fairfield schools this is an auction you will not want to miss!

15144 County Road 50, Syracuse

Listing courtesy of Jesse Riegsecker from Bright Star Real Estate Services LLC. office: 574-821-7653

$899,900

3 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 202638321 MLS ⋅ 5,336 SqFt. ⋅ Andy Walker

Distinctive French Country-inspired architecture, beautiful natural stone, and a wonderfully private wooded setting create an unforgettable first impression at this one-of-a-kind Bloomington home. Steeply pitched gables, decorative timber detailing, an arched entry, and mature landscaping give the exterior timeless European character, while the interior offers over 5000 square feet of distinctive and exceptionally flexible living space across three levels. Graceful arched openings, rich wood trim, custom millwork, slate flooring, fireplaces, and architectural details carry the home’s character throughout. One of its most exceptional features is the floor plan, with a spacious private bedroom suite on every level, creating wonderful possibilities for multigenerational living, extended-stay guests, or simply giving everyone their own private retreat. The main level features an expansive primary suite along with generous living and dining areas, a well-appointed kitchen, and striking entertaining spaces. A dramatic room accented by substantial wood molding, arched openings, a brick fireplace, and distinctive slate-and-wood flooring showcases the craftsmanship and personality found throughout the home. Upstairs, another generous bedroom suite is complemented by a large loft and additional flexible rooms that can accommodate offices, hobbies, reading areas, or other needs. The expansive lower level feels like a home of its own, offering yet another private bedroom suite along with a large recreation room, second kitchen, fireplace, pantry, utility space, and abundant room for entertaining or extended living. Surrounded by mature trees and lush greenery, the property offers an impressive sense of privacy while remaining convenient to Bloomington. Three levels, three private suites, multiple living spaces, multiple fireplaces, and tremendous flexibility make this a truly distinctive property—one that can comfortably evolve with the needs of its next owner.

5500 E Ariel Way, Bloomington

Listing courtesy of Andy Walker from RE/MAX Acclaimed Properties. Cell: 812-325-1290

$725,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202633340 MLS ⋅ 1,116 SqFt. ⋅ Tarah Cromer

Direct waterfront living on Lake Lemon awaits you at this charming 2 bedroom, 1 bath lake house in Unionville, Indiana. Lake Lemon spans 1,650 acres with 24 miles of shoreline, one of Indiana's largest lakes, and offers plenty of open water for boating, water skiing, and fishing. Enjoy sweeping views of the water right from your living room and front porch, plus the convenience of your own private dock just steps away. This home sits close to some of the lake's best swimming spots and Riddle Point, making it easy to spend your days on the water and your evenings soaking in the sunset. The low maintenance yard means more time enjoying the lake and less time on upkeep. Inside you will find thoughtful updates throughout including nice cabinetry, newer countertops, and a newer furnace, so the hard work is already done for you. The oversized 2 car garage is heated and insulated, offering year round storage or workshop space, and the layout gives you great options to expand later, whether that means going up for more living space or finishing out the attached garage. Whether you are looking for a full time residence or the ultimate weekend getaway, this property offers the lake lifestyle you have been dreaming of, just a short drive from Bloomington. Properties with direct waterfront access and a dock are hard to come by on this lake, so opportunities like this do not last long. It is not too late to grab your lake house before the season ends. Priced at $725,000, this is your chance to own a slice of Lake Lemon and start making memories right away. Schedule your showing today and see why life is better on the water.

7669 N John Young Rd, Unionville

Listing courtesy of Tarah Cromer from RE/MAX Acclaimed Properties. Cell: 812-360-8015

$940,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202632548 MLS ⋅ 1,456 SqFt. ⋅ Lavinia Chudy

Discover over 77 acres of privacy, recreation, and possibility in beautiful Unionville. This unique 3-bedroom, 2-bath property offers an incredible blend of open pasture and heavily wooded acreage, backing up to state forest for an exceptional outdoor setting. Established trails wind through the woods, creating opportunities for horseback riding, ATVs, UTVs, hiking, hunting, and exploring right from your own property. The acreage is well suited for horses, with fenced pasture, horse stalls, and multiple outbuildings offering plenty of space for animals, equipment, recreational gear, storage, and hobbies. Honey Creek runs through the property, adding to the natural beauty and character of the land. The home features three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, an indoor workshop, and an outdoor deck surrounded by the peaceful setting. A detached two-car garage provides additional parking and workspace, along with a finished storage room above for even more versatility. The exterior of the home was freshly painted in 2025, and the gas furnace was also new in 2025. The home additionally features an electric heat pump and a Woodchuck wood-burning furnace, providing multiple heating options. Whether you're searching for an equestrian property, recreational retreat, hunting land, or simply the privacy and freedom that comes with owning more than 77 acres, this property offers a rare combination of pasture, woods, water, trails, and usable improvements in one remarkable setting.

8310 N Low Gap Rd, Unionville

Listing courtesy of Lavinia Chudy from Century 21 Scheetz - Bloomington. cell: 630-346-9647

$465,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202631848 MLS ⋅ 4,128 SqFt. ⋅ Betty Mullis

LISTED BELOW APPRAISED VALUE! Enjoy the perfect blend of space, comfort, and location in this beautifully maintained home just minutes from Indiana University and Indiana University Hospital, with a short commute to I-69. Situated on a scenic 1-acre lot in Unionville, this property offers a peaceful setting with convenient access to town. A welcoming covered front porch adds to the home’s charm and provides the perfect place to relax and enjoy the surroundings. Inside, you’ll find a spacious kitchen with plenty of room for cooking, gathering, and everyday living—perfect for entertaining or simply enjoying extra workspace. Just off the main living areas, the enclosed back porch offers a comfortable space to enjoy the outdoors year-round. The home features 3 bedrooms on the main level, including a comfortable primary suite with a walk-in closet and private bath. The main floor also includes a convenient laundry room and a dedicated office space—ideal for working from home. The fully finished basement is designed for entertaining, offering a large game room, additional dining area, and a kitchenette space already plumbed for a sink—ready for your finishing touches. Major updates include a new roof (2017), water heater (2020), and AC (2025), giving you peace of mind for years to come. Additional highlights include a 2-car attached garage, generous living spaces, and a beautiful 1-acre setting. This is a wonderful opportunity to enjoy space, comfort, and convenience!

6440 E State Road 45, Bloomington

Listing courtesy of Betty Mullis from Bear Real Estate Sales.

$998,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202627366 MLS ⋅ 3,008 SqFt. ⋅ Kristi Gibbs

Remodeled by renowned Loren Wood Builders, this four-story timber-frame home is nestled on 10 wooded acres, where striking architectural character, modern design, and exceptional versatility come together. A residential elevator provides convenient access to all four levels, enhancing both everyday living and long-term functionality. Outside, enjoy 10 acres of lush, wooded beauty enhanced by curated landscaping, including hydrangeas, azaleas, rhododendrons, roses, daffodils, and irises. The rustic cedar and concrete board siding, along with a standing seam roof and whole-house generator, lend durability, peace of mind, and style to the exterior. A striking architectural breezeway connects to a 2-car garage, while a separate heated and cooled 1,500+ sq ft workshop with a full bath and plumbed for a kitchen offers flexible space for hobbies, boat storage for nearby Lake Lemon, or the potential to create an income-producing or guest space with additional improvements. Inside, the home's main level features two spacious bedrooms, two full baths, laundry, and a cozy office with built-in desk and shelving made from reclaimed ceiling joists and rafters. Upstairs, the bespoke kitchen features quartz countertops, rift-sawn white oak cabinetry handcrafted by Stoll’s Woodworking, Wolf appliances, and a picturesque window that frames the landscape like art. Expansive windows flood the nearby living room with natural light, highlighting the sweeping forest views. Sliding doors connect the living and dining rooms with the upper level Massaranduba Brazilian hardwood deck, the perfect location for outdoor meals or relaxing. The 3rd floor primary suite is a true sanctuary, complete with heated floors and towel rack, curbless walk-in shower, custom mirrors that fold to maximize views, and a spacious walk-in closet outfitted with extensive built-in storage. The walk-out basement offers storage space and options for additional customization, conveniently connected to the upper levels by the elevator. Wide-plank European oak flooring flows throughout, complemented by a striking modern staircase of wood and steel with a custom metal railing. This truly exceptional property offers a rare combination of privacy, exceptional craftsmanship, and the flexibility to evolve with changing needs.

7654 N Shilo Rd, Unionville

Listing courtesy of Kristi Gibbs from Century 21 Scheetz - Bloomington.

$695,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202605657 MLS ⋅ 2,880 SqFt. ⋅ Jennifer Woods

Surrounded by Yellowwood and Morgan/Monroe State Forests, this beautifully crafted all suite, four-bedroom, four-bathroom cabin offers natural charm with modern touches. 10 gorgeous acres of protected forest is the setting for this custom designed cabin, handcrafted from solid poplar logs (this is a NOT a kit home). The spacious main living area features soaring vaulted ceiling and a cozy stone clad gas fireplace. An expansive wall of windows bathes the space in natural light. An easy flowing open floor plan connects the living room to a fully equipped kitchen with plenty of cabinets, a central island, a pantry and space for a dining table. A large loft above overlooks the main level and provides an extra room for relaxation, a home office, or a family room/game area. There is a huge drywalled walk-in storage room upstairs as well. There are two bedroom ensuites with bathrooms located on the main level and each has access to outdoor deck space to enjoy your morning coffee or an evening sunset. The fully finished walkout basement includes two guest quarter bedrooms with ensuite baths and their own private entrances. Additionally, one has a sitting room adjacent to it. This space is perfect for family, visitors or potential rental income. They are currently income producing and are frequently rented by the day or week. Outside, the deck wraps completely around the cabin and the lower level has a patio area and a separate deck. An extra large detached garage offers ample space for vehicles, tools and outdoor gear. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, a weekend getaway, or a potential investment property, this stunning log cabin delivers that cozy cabin charm you've been seeking, conveniently located in the sweet spot between Bloomington and Nashville!!! The hot tub and some interior furnishings may be negotiable. The adjacent 4 BR vacation rental cabin at 1291 N Sewell Road is also available for sale, MLS #202605654

1275 N Sewell Rd, Bloomington

Listing courtesy of Jennifer Woods from FC Tucker/Bloomington REALTORS. jwoods@homefinder.org

$989,000

4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 202628552 MLS ⋅ 6,669 SqFt. ⋅ Jeff Franklin

Just minutes from Indiana University, but tucked away on a private road, is this brick home surrounded on 6.55 acres of wooded beauty. This custom home with beautiful natural textures on all three levels has stunning views. This earthy home with two geothermal units has skylights, passive solar and beautiful custom features that include curved stair, beautiful fireplace and spacious bedrooms. The main level primary suite has a luxury bath that’s been updated and has serene views of the garden. The upper level bedrooms are ensuite, have a loft overlook and also feature a secondary stair and additional storage area. This home on a ridge has built-ins throughout and a beautifully updated kitchen with induction stove, recent appliances, and a beautiful built-in eat-in breakfast room. The finished lower level features a wonderful recreation room that walks out to a stupendous south facing lawn surrounded by mature trees on the perimeter. There is a detached gardening utility garage that is great for outdoor entertaining. James Road in Kingston Estates is one of Bloomington‘s favorite established neighborhoods that is on a cul-de-sac with neighbors on estate sized sites. Pop into Bloomingfoods in three minutes from this conveniently located home that feels separated from it all, but is close to everything. Great access to Indiana University, College Mall, and Bloomington’s cultural activities

5430 E James Rd, Bloomington

Listing courtesy of Jeff Franklin from FC Tucker/Bloomington REALTORS. franklin@tuckerbloomington.com

Start Your Search

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.